Showing posts with label Peter Singer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Peter Singer. Show all posts

Wednesday, 11 July 2012

Nuns, orthodoxy and the media

More about nuns and media
Apologies if this rambles a bit, but I would like to start collecting some of these ideas.

Past posts on this site have been critical of unorthodoxy in religious life, including with some nuns. They will probably continue to be so – but it should also be considered that dissent from orthodox positions is not always harmful, certainly need not be so, and can sometimes be of benefit to the orthodox position.

American nuns
I recently watched some interviews with Sister Joan Chittister, an American Benedictine. She is a regular (secular and religious) media interviewee, very intelligent and well spoken. She also conveys a natural sense of compassion and mercy in the way that she interviews, which I find sort of makes you want to agree with her. 

Also, and like anyone who notices the religious media, and of course the secular media when religious issues boil over the divide, I am aware of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious’ dissent against the Church’s criticism of aspects of their views following an apostolic visitation and doctrinal assessment. This has lead to a nun-driven US bus tour (‘Nuns on the bus’ - only in America, which also protested some Republican proposed budget measures) and a secular media flare-up following the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith’s censure of Sr Margaret Farley’s book Just Love: A Framework for Christian Sexual Ethics.

Sr Margaret Farley is also reported as being a particularly genuine and reflective person, which I imagine is true.

Nonetheless, these women raise issues that do not fall squarely within Church doctrine. What I would like to examine here is how this matter is approached publically. That is, what are the circumstances in which you and I come to hear about it, as we most likely do not know any of the protagonists first hand.

Firstly, there is the way in which such issues are presented in the secular media. Secondly, there is the way in which the Church itself, without recourse to the secular media, approaches views of members in dissent. The first of these – the secular media approach – only seems to have the capacity to distort reality and divide. The second, which probably cannot be successfully presented in the secular media, can be of benefit to all Church members for different reasons.

Media issues
Needless to say, the issues raised by the Church and the nuns have found themselves in the secular media. Why is that? I think it is because it allows presentation of a dispute which is attractive to subscribers to that media. The general approach, so it seems to me, is for the doctrinal issues raised by the Church to be portrayed as a cruel and calculating bishop-driven, out-of-touch-Vatican stomping upon innocent, lovable nuns (Get Religion has many posts on this, see also Russel Reno’s recent post on First Things ). This style of reportign was probably best exemplified with the press coverage of Sr Farley’s book

It should be trite to observe that such coverage seems to benefit nobody. I suspect that it must also offer the ‘darlings’ of the story the temptation of power – they are media currency and can have their views expressed in the public (for a time) seemingly at will. An Australian exemplar of this occured a few years ago with (the now former) Fr Peter Kennedy – the parish priest of St Mary’s in South Brisbane who lost the plot (including placing Buddhist statues in his Church), and became an ABC favourite for a few weeks, only to now be forgotten. In respect of the recent US nuns issue see here for example, ).

And now for the good in all of this
I do not agree with Sr Joan’s positions on most matters, and nor with Sr Farley (not that I am a scholar of either of their views in any depth). However, I regard their positions to be of value for two reasons.

The first is that these women seem to me to present their views in a respectful and non-confrontational manner. They also appreciate that their views on some issues are not those of the Church. That they can present their views shows that the Catholic Church is a broad church in which people can express different views which can be discussed. This does not change the Church teaching, but it shows that the problem to disagreement is not simply to silence or expel people, or for people to think that have no recourse but to break away (as it feel is more of a pressure point in the Anglican Church).

It reminds me of Robert Frost’s poem A Minor Bird:
I have wished a bird would fly away,
And not sing by my house all day;

Have clapped my hands at him from the door
When it seemed as if I could bear no more.

The fault must partly have been in me.
The bird was not to blame for his key.

And of course there must be something wrong
In wanting to silence any song.

A chance for spring cleaning
The second point is that serious consideration (not acceptance) of such positions should be taken seriously as a means to reaching a deeper orthodox theology and understanding of the Church. Quoting from Michael Novak’s recent book No One Sees God (considering confronting atheism), arguments that try and cut across your own position can often be beneficial.

“[They] awaken [you] from complacency, force [you] to confront new arguments and to think more deeply about older ones. It tempers the hubris, self-satisfaction, and unreasoning enthusiasm too often visible among people of faith. It pops balloons of airy assumptions and facile answers. It hoists complacent believers on the petard of their carelessness self-contradictions. It invites the minds of believers to become firmer, sharper and tougher."
In other words, carefully considering the arguments of those opposed to you, you gain the chance to strengthen your own position by dealing with your opponent’s view of the matter, which you may not have realised to that point in time.

An abortion example
I think one current example of this, but from the other side of the spectrum, is Peter Singer’s position on abortion.

As I understand Singer’s argument, he differs from most (at least from my experience) pro-abortion people. Singer does not assert that an unborn child is not deserving of legal protection on the basis that it is not a living being. He accepts that it is, and
regards arguments otherwise as resorting
“to a convenient fiction that turns an evidently living being into one that legally is not alive.”

I take it that such an argument is unorthodox to pro-abortionists. If it was put by a pro-lifer, it would be a heretical pronouncement, since (as I imagine it) for the pro-abortionist if the unborn are living, then much of their argument is undermined. But if considered as an argument by Singer (someone in their camp), it can be considered as something with which they seriously need to contend. It needs to be weighed up. (Hopefully, it would be accepted, but that this would lead to a pro-life position on the basis that they could not then accept Singer’s next proposition that morally some life does not warrant protection.)

So too it can be with the positions of the Sisters. Their arguments should give us occasion to sharpen our own positions by reflecting on their own.

Monday, 11 June 2012

All hail Peter Singer?

Each year at this time, Australians are bestowed with 'Queen's Birthday awards', leading to a morning of public broadcaster radio coverage of interviews with understandably humbled recipients.

To get a news story out of such an event, focus tends to be on a famous scientist or doctor, whose work has led to discovering a technique in treating some form of terrible suffering. This year that person is medical researcher Ian Frazer. 

A second angle for a story is to pick up on a controversial (if only slightly) recipient.  This year, that person seems to be Peter Singer.

You may have heard of Peter Singer. He's famous for animal liberation and (but only secondly) encouraging the killing of humans in circumstances currently just beyond the norm - like killing intellectually or physically disabled children at any time in the first few years after birth (in particular circumstances).  (If you are interested in a punchy critique of Singer's views in this respect, try and find a copy of James Franklin's book on the history of philosophy in Australia - Corrupting the Youth, which is well worth a read anyway).

Mr Singer's views have always tended to secure an disproportional amount of media coverage by the Australian and British public broadcasters.  This is not, as the uneducated may imagine, in order to critique his position, but to effectively sing his praises, albeit with a bit of weak counterposed opposition lacking his formidable rigour. (This last observation links back to a previous post concerning the potential harm that can flow from having opposition on these issues pushed through a purely Christian point of view, and not spiced with significant rigour .)

In any event, in today's interviews with Mr Singer, talk quickly progressed to his views of God. Singer is also wheeled out as a 'new aethist', commonly at those other events so lovingly covered by public broadcasters - conferences of atheists with their Parthenon of stars - Dawkins et al.  The interviewer asked Singer a question along the lines of 'we know you have strong views of rationalism over belief in God, so you must be very disappointed to learn that the amount of followers of religion is continuing to grow.'  'Yes', said Singer (and I'm paraphrasing), 'I can only try an promote the place of rational thought' - and so it went on.

I have three comments about this. First, it seems to be assumed, in the question asked and answer given, that if you are religious, you are not rational.  This is a great convenience for an interviewer, since (amongst other things) it prevents any potential embarrassment between interviewer and intervieweee.

Second, it is sad that the subject matter of  the question (that religion is growing) is treated as little more than a position to hold in a debate, or as being akin to a political view that can change between elections. The tone has no room to consider that a religious position reflects a way of life for a person.  Marriage is now treated the same way - as though it is something to be supported or not, rather than as a way of being.

Thirdly, and this brings me to Burwood library. No doubt you have never heard of Burwood library - a suburban local public library in Sydney, but you may be able to identify with the following, drawn to my attention by my wife (and for a more substantial future post).  If you went and had a look at the books in the religious section (say, out of a sociological interest), you would discover that there are very few - I'd say less than 5% - which would give you any insight as to how to live as a Catholic (my creed). There are plenty that tell you how to live as an atheist, and why that is a superior state of being.  There are many others about lapsed believers who take a swing at their former profession, there are may 'comparative religion' books and finally, there are plenty of Kumbaya books (see up and to the right for a definition). In short, unlike the art, cooking, history and chemistry sections, there are not many books about how to be a Catholic in a religion section.

I suppose the point can be viewed as to how has religion's role in large parts of the 'public square' has been reduced to cannon fodder for attackers (a la Singer and his mates), or something of a sociological phenomenon (al la Burwood library), rather than something that most of us humans do?  All for another day.