Showing posts with label gay parenting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gay parenting. Show all posts

Monday, 18 June 2012

Shining marriage pastoral letter

The Catholic Archbishop of Sydney, and his auxiliary bishops, issued a pastoral letter on marriage yesterday. At least to me, the letter concisely ventilated the central issues in the 'same-sex marriage' debate, with a focus on children and the role of chastity. I also found it comforting and uplifting to have a pastoral letter read out, as opposed to being made available for collection on the way out of Mass.  In essence the letter said 'we are Catholics and these are the reasons (which were then summarised) why we Catholics oppose the idea that there can be such a thing as same sex marriage'.

Given that anything 'gay' attracts massive levels of media attention, seemingly on demand, the usual opposition was rolled out, and probably in the belief that balanced coverage was being provided. 

As is to be expected, the ABC led the charge.  Its website ran several stories referring to the letter and similar letters read to other Christian churches.  For a rather atheistic institution, you'd be forgiven for thinking that they honestly believed that the letter had been drafted by the devil himself. 

Today's lead ran with the headline: "Pastor slams anti-gay marriage campaign", and rather ironically given the headline, accused the Church of scaremongering.   The 'pastor' referred to was a Baptist minister from Sydney who is a common go-to man when a pro gay marriage line is needed from a Christian, and he faithfully delivered.  He was concerned that Catholics could not think for themselves.

Of course, there can rarely be a gay 'marriage' story without a contribution from the Greens, who in the same ABC story took the view that it was all scaremongering because (now get this) the proposed laws would not force Catholics to perform same-sex 'marriages'. (I'm not sure whether the Greens or the ABC actually read the letter they were commenting upon.)

Similarly themed stories were run in the Sydney Morning Herald who wheeled out Penny Wong with a 'gay marriage is inevitable' line. News Limited, and it must be said somewhat originally, went to the trouble of finding a comment from the pop singer from Savage Garden, who it turned out was quite upset by it all. 

The only thing missing in the thousands and thousands of words devoted to the event was coverage of what the letter actually said, why Catholics and other Christians had concerns, what those concerns were, and how the 'gay groups' (and, I suppose, the Baptist minister) responded to these positions. For instance, I could not find a link to the letter on any news piece. 

Now, it is not uncommon to refer to all of this as a debate, but there does not seem to be much debating going on.

Thursday, 7 June 2012

Surrogacy laws and media coverage

I have just come across a report of a recent NSW Supreme Court decision concerning the operation of the Surrogacy Act to two men. The two men have become the parents of a child by application of the Act.

Before commenting on the decision, and the issues generally thrown up (which are being saved for another post), there are some things to note in respect of the news coverage.  Firstly, there was not much at all, which is a bit funny given that this seems to be the first application of the Act to two men.  Secondly, the news was focused through a Christian lens. The stories all quoted from a statement by the Australian Christian Lobby (ACL) which was reported to have "condemned" the decision, or more properly the practical operation of the Act.

I suppose that a counterpoint between 'gay' and 'Christian' makes for an easy story, but to me it can too easily operate as a way of avoiding what should be treated as a serious social issue, and not an ideological battle. I would hope that the ACL people do not hold onto their views simply because they are Christian, but also because their view is the most reasonable position to take on an issue, and ought to be adopted regardless of creed.  This is a theme I would like to consider more fully (again in future posts). It throws up issues like lazy journalism. It also gives occasion to wonder about the effectiveness of lobby groups like the ACL given their relative success in gaining media coverage on issues of this type. Does this have a propensity to harm one side of a debate by allowing it to be too easily caricatured as fundamentalist? Does it marginalise the issue in an unhealthy way?  Anyhow, something for another day.

Tuesday, 5 June 2012

Obama’s doing it, why can’t we?




Hopefully you have not noticed, but there is a new campaign being run to enable you to show your support for same-sex marriage (if you must, see ido.org.au).  There are three protagonists.   

Marie Claire magazine, whose July edition (and besides the gay marriage hook), proves its love for diversity by (and this is not a joke) dealing with issues such as ‘my life as a porn writer’, ‘hoodie hysteria - when fashion turns deadly’ and ‘why you need a 5 year life plan’.  Obviously, the sort of serious publication that springs to mind when confronting the social issues of the day.  

Then there is Sunrise, the Channel 7 morning television program. Even if you’ve never seen it, you know the type of thing: the lovable bantering breaky team that you just feel you know.

And finally, Get-up, a social change group, that I suppose is something of a legitimate voice in this debate.

On a serious note, (so what to do with Marie Claire?) this issue does throw up some points worth commenting on. 

Firstly, and like many social issues, the pro and con camps quickly polarise and form into ‘CFZs’ – communication free zones.  Whilst we are all seemingly having a jolly old debate, and indeed using words from the very same dictionary, there is a stop upon the engagement and communication needed to resolve, or at least understand, key issues.

In the marriage debate, the CFZ appears to be over what marriage is. Is it about a public affirmation of love, and nothing more? Is it about enabling procreation in a stable environment and nothing more? Is it about ensuring social stability and children being raised by their mother and father? Etc. Clearly these are questions that need some serious thought.  They are also given it elsewhere (compare academics like Robert P George (Princeton) and Jenni Millbank (UTS Sydney)). Maybe we should read the ‘my life as a porn writer’ article for answers? (I’m also assuming that it is an article.)

Next comes the ‘social isolation’ aspect (a good writer on this topic is Bishop Charles Chaput, see most recently: A Heart on Fire: Catholic Witness and the Next America). I expect that if the person next to you on the bus was reading Marie Claire, you’d not really care.  There is certainly no faux pas. The point being that the more you are told, told and told that gay marriage is a ‘no brainer’, that not having it is a ‘denial of human rights’, that it is ‘inevitable’, the more you are punched into acceptance, if only acceptance by your silent disagreement.   


The last point I’d like to make concerns the statistical aspect to all of this. We are told, and I have no reason to doubt, that there is a consistently surveyed majority that in some way are not opposed to gay marriage.  These are often called the supporters on the issue.  I suspect that many branded supporters are perhaps better described as apathetic – along the lines of  ‘well if they want to get married, good luck to them, what do I care?’ 

The statistical representations, both mathematically and philosophically, require some further consideration.  For instance, how should an apathetic attitude be represented? Probably by having other categories besides ‘for’ and ‘against’.  Should there be some consideration given to those who support gay marriage but place no value on marriage between men and women? I recently read a statistic in (I think) First Things about the percentage of adults in the USA who are not married, and it was high.  How should this be dealt with?

Anyhow, some things to think about.